US ResearchConflictsEarly Republic and War of 1812Spanish-Comanche Peace Treaty
Early Republic and War of 1812

Spanish-Comanche Peace Treaty

1786
New Mexico
Era
Early Republic and War of 1812
Year
1786
Location
New Mexico
Status
Historical record
The Combatants

Who Fought

Forces
Not recorded in historical accounts
VS
Victor
Not recorded in historical accounts
Outcome
The two Comanche-Spanish peace treaties of 1785 and 1786 resulted in a permanent peace between the Comanche and the Spanish colony of Santa Fe de Nuevo México, and a lengthy, albeit interrupted, peace between the Comanche and the Spanish in Texas. The treaties led to expanded trade and a combined military effort against their mutual Apache enemy, with New Mexico effectively becoming a Comanche protectorate until Mexican independence in 1821.
The Battle

History & Significance

Since their first contacts with the Spanish in 1706, the Comanches had raided Spanish colonies in New Mexico and Texas, posing a significant threat to their continued existence. By the mid-eighteenth century, the Comanche threat to Spanish settlements had become critical. In the 1780s, several factors combined to give both the Spanish and Comanche incentives to negotiate peace treaties, leading to the treaties of 1785 and 1786.

These peace treaties resulted in a permanent peace between the Comanche in Comancheria and the Spanish colony of Santa Fe de Nuevo México, as well as a lengthy, albeit interrupted, peace between the Comanche and the Spanish in Texas. The treaties brought about significant changes in relations between the two sides, including expanded trade between the Spanish and the Comanche.

The historical consequence of these treaties was substantial and long-lasting. The agreements essentially transformed New Mexico into a protectorate of the Comanche from the 1780s until 1821. The treaties also enabled a combined effort by the Spanish and Comanche to defeat their mutual enemy, the Apache. This arrangement persisted until the success of the Mexican War of Independence in 1821, which ended the treaties and fundamentally altered the political landscape of the region.

Historical context

The early republic period saw the United States move from the weak Articles of Confederation to the federal Constitution ratified in 1788, with the Bill of Rights added in 1791. George Washington served two terms as president (1789–1797), establishing precedents for executive authority, and the federal capital moved permanently to Washington D.C. in 1800. The Louisiana Purchase (1803) doubled the nation's territory for roughly $15 million, opening vast trans-Mississippi lands to American expansion. The War of 1812 against Britain ended inconclusively but produced a surge of American national identity and eliminated most British support for Indigenous resistance east of the Mississippi. The Northwest Indian Wars (1785–1795) and the Creek War (1813–1814) broke Indigenous confederacies that had resisted US expansion. The Missouri Compromise of 1820 temporarily balanced slave and free states as the nation expanded westward, but embedded the contradiction of slavery in every subsequent territorial debate.

Questions & Answers

Frequently Asked Questions

When did Spanish-Comanche Peace Treaty take place?
Spanish-Comanche Peace Treaty took place in 1786.
Where was Spanish-Comanche Peace Treaty fought?
Spanish-Comanche Peace Treaty was fought in New Mexico, United States.
What was the outcome of Spanish-Comanche Peace Treaty?
The two Comanche-Spanish peace treaties of 1785 and 1786 resulted in a permanent peace between the Comanche and the Spanish colony of Santa Fe de Nuevo México, and a lengthy, albeit interrupted, peace between the Comanche and the Spanish in Texas. The treaties led to expanded trade and a combined military effort against their mutual Apache enemy, with New Mexico effectively becoming a Comanche protectorate until Mexican independence in 1821.
What was the significance of Spanish-Comanche Peace Treaty?
Since their first contacts with the Spanish in 1706, the Comanches had raided Spanish colonies in New Mexico and Texas, posing a significant threat to their continued existence. By the mid-eighteenth century, the Comanche threat to Spanish settlements had become critical. In the 1780s, several facto
Protected heritage nearby

Historic Sites near Spanish-Comanche Peace Treaty

Federal Building
Early Republic · 0 mi
Santa Fe Plaza
Colonial · 0.1 mi
Palace of the Governors
Colonial · 0.1 mi
Fort Marcy Officer's Residence
Civil War · 0.1 mi
More from this era

Other Early Republic and War of 1812 Engagements

Price Expedition – Navajo 1847
1847
New Mexico
Taos Revolt — Battle of Taos Pueblo
1847
New Mexico
Newby Expedition – Navajo 1848
1848
New Mexico
Battle of Washington Pass NM
1849
New Mexico
Washington Expedition – Narbona Killed
1849
New Mexico
All battles in New Mexico
Source

Content adapted from Wikipedia under the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.

Aubrey Research

Explore the history around New Mexico

Aubrey generates in-depth historical research for any location in the US, drawing on NRHP records, battlefield archives, census history and geological data to tell the full story of a place.

Research a location near New MexicoView a free sample report
All Early Republic and War of 1812 Battles