BattlefieldsBattle of Matilda
modern

Battle of Matilda

1812
Scotland
Era
modern
Battle Type
Pitched Battle
Location
Scotland
Status
Unregistered
The Combatants

Who Fought

Defeated
American forces (New York Militia)
VS
Victor
British and Canadian forces
Outcome
British and Canadian forces successfully repulsed the American attack, capturing an American boat along with muskets and provisions. The Americans were driven from Presqu'ile Island and retreated across the St. Lawrence River.
The Battle

History & Significance

The Battle of Matilda, also known as the Battle of Toussaint's Island, was an early skirmish of the War of 1812 fought on 16 September 1812 along the St. Lawrence River near the township of Matilda in Dundas County. With the outbreak of war in June 1812, the county militias along the St. Lawrence had mustered for active service, with men of the Dundas Militia and Grenville Militia guarding the shoreline from Prescott to the Long Sault rapids and providing protection for supply convoys travelling between Cornwall and Kingston. The New York militia had likewise assembled along the river and begun planning raids across it.

Soldiers from the 1st Flank Company of the 1st Dundas Regiment under Captain Michael Ault and Ensign Duncan Clark, together with soldiers under Major Rowland Heathcote of the Royal Newfoundland Regiment, were escorting a supply shipment from Montreal to Kingston when they were attacked by approximately 500 American militia under Captain Griffin, who had concealed themselves on Toussaint Island. A company of the Dundas Militia under Ensign Clark landed on Presqu'ile Island, only to find an American force landing simultaneously; a sharp exchange of fire ensued. The Dundas men, concealed amongst the bushes and trees, pinned down the Americans with accurate fire and forced them to retreat back to Toussaint's Island. During the hasty American withdrawal, one of their boats drifted away and was captured by the Dundas militia, containing seven muskets, two swords, and a quantity of provisions.

Drawn by the noise of battle, additional Dundas militiamen arrived on Presqu'ile to reinforce the Canadian positions. Colonel Allan MacDonell, commanding the Dundas Militia, was joined by Captain Shaver and Captain Ault, along with two companies of Grenville Militia under Captains Monroe and Dulmage. Lieutenant Richard Duncan Fraser brought a 9-pounder artillery piece from Prescott, a gun that had originally been captured at the Battle of the Thousand Islands. After a few rounds from the cannon and muskets, the Americans abandoned the island and retreated across the St. Lawrence to the New York shore. Canadian losses amounted to one man killed and several wounded, while the Americans were reported to have suffered considerable losses.

Suspected site. The exact location is uncertain.
Buried history

During the engagement on Presqu'ile Island, the Dundas militia, concealed amongst the bushes and trees, pinned the numerically superior American force down with accurate fire, forcing them into a hasty retreat to Toussaint's Island; in the confusion one American boat drifted away from their force and was captured, found to contain seven muskets, two swords, and a number of provisions. The arrival of Lieutenant Richard Duncan Fraser with a 9-pounder artillery piece, originally taken at the Battle of the Thousand Islands, proved decisive, and after a few rounds of cannon and musket fire the Americans abandoned their position entirely and withdrew across the St. Lawrence to New York.

Casualties & Losses

Canadian: one killed, several wounded. American: described as considerable losses.

Forces Involved

British/Canadian: 1st Dundas Regiment (1st Flank Company under Capt. Michael Ault and Ens. Duncan Clark; sedentary companies under Capts. Adam Shaver and John Munro), 1st and 2nd Grenville Militia flank companies (Capts. Hugh Monroe and Philip Dulmadge, Lt. Richard D. Fraser), Royal Newfoundland Fencibles detachment under Maj. Rowland Heathcote, plus a 9-pounder artillery piece. American: approximately 500 New York Militia under Capt. Griffin, supported by a gun boat.

Questions & Answers

Frequently Asked Questions

Unlimited access

Uncover the history of anywhere in the UK

Pick any location and Aubrey pulls together everything the record actually holds about it:

GeologyDomesday BookLocal findsScheduled monumentsRoman BritainBattlefieldsCivil WarLIDAR terrainLocal namesHistorical mapsLiteratureFull timeline
First month just £4.99, then £9.99 a month. Unlimited locations, cancel anytime.

Every location is different. Not every section appears for every place, only what the historical record actually holds turns up in a report.

Start your first month for £4.99
Aubrey Research

Explore the landscape around this battlefield

Aubrey generates in-depth historical research for any location in the UK — drawing on Domesday records, scheduled monuments, Victorian OS maps, geological data and archaeological archives to tell the full story of a place.

Research a location near this battlefieldView a sample report
Sources